Can Understanding People Make You Better at Hurting Them?
We often assume that the people who understand us best are the people least likely to hurt us. We associate emotional intelligence with empathy as well as the ability to form meaningful relationships. Yet, what if understanding someone makes it easier to hurt them? Knowing what makes a person feel valued also means knowing what makes them feel inadequate. Recognising someone’s insecurities can allow us to reassure them, but it can equally allow us to exploit them. The ability to understand another person’s emotions is therefore not necessarily an indication of goodwill. In some circumstances, it may be precisely what makes manipulation possible.
Emotional intelligence (EI), introduced by Salovey and Mayer (1990) [11], refers to the ability to understand and manage emotions in both ourselves and others [6]. It is commonly celebrated as an essential quality for communication and healthy relationships [2]. However, I argue that emotional intelligence should not automatically be equated with someone’s moral character [12]. Understanding how someone feels does not necessarily mean caring about how they feel. In fact, the same abilities that allow individuals to build meaningful relationships may also enable them to use those abilities for the purpose of manipulation.
Consider the difference between recognising an insecurity that someone may have, and choosing what to do with that knowledge. An emotionally aware individual may recognise that another person seeks validation, or struggles with self-confidence. This understanding can often be used to offer reassurance, but it can also be used to create dependence, or even exploitation. Emotional manipulation does not always require overt malice; sometimes, it involves knowing exactly which buttons to press [5].
Research on the Dark Triad [8], which consists of narcissism (extreme self-obsession and need for admiration), Machiavellianism (calculated manipulation for personal gain), and psychopathy (impulsive behavior with a lack of empathy), complicates the assumption that emotional intelligence is inherently prosocial. Petrides et al. (2011) [9] found that trait emotional intelligence was positively associated with narcissism, even though it was negatively associated with Machiavellianism and psychopathy. Casale et al. (2019) [3] similarly highlighted the relationship between certain narcissistic characteristics and emotional manipulation. These findings suggest that emotional awareness can coexist with personality traits that prioritise personal interests over the well-being of others [1]. However, this does not mean that narcissism or manipulation is an inevitable consequence of high emotional intelligence, but it instead challenges the assumption that emotional understanding necessarily produces considerate behaviour.
On another note, understanding emotions also means understanding how those emotions are communicated. We rely heavily on facial expressions, tone of voice, and body language to interpret the intentions of others. But what happens when these signals can be deliberately controlled? According to models of emotional intelligence, management of emotions includes the idea of masking or even reiterating what you physically express.
Porter et al. (2011) [10] linked emotional intelligence to the ability to simulate convincing emotional expressions. This raises an uncomfortable possibility: that someone may know how to appear sympathetic without genuinely feeling sympathy, or express concern without intending to offer support. Emotional regulation, usually celebrated as a valuable interpersonal skill, can therefore become a tool for managing the impressions others form of us. I believe that this distinction matters greatly, as we often mistake emotional expression for emotional experience. A convincing display of concern is not necessarily evidence of compassion. The ability to communicate emotions convincingly does not guarantee that those emotions are genuine.
Perhaps the most important distinction in this debate is between cognitive and affective empathy. Cognitive empathy involves understanding another person’s emotional experience, whereas affective empathy involves sharing or emotionally responding to it. These abilities may overlap, but they are not interchangeable. Nguyen et al. (2020) [7], in a meta-analysis examining emotional intelligence and emotional manipulation, found that their relationship varied depending on how EI was defined and measured. This reinforces the idea that emotional intelligence is not a uniformly positive characteristic. Some forms of emotional ability may facilitate manipulation, while others may be associated with more prosocial behaviour [4].
This is why emotional intelligence should not be treated as a measure of morality. An individual may understand exactly how their actions affect another person and still choose to proceed. In this sense, emotional intelligence provides knowledge, but it does not dictate ethics.
Of course, it would be unfair to suggest that emotional intelligence is inherently manipulative. Understanding someone’s distress can help us respond with compassion, while recognising our own emotional reactions can prevent unnecessary conflict. Of course, research also suggests that certain dimensions of EI are associated with prosocial forms of interpersonal behaviour [2].
However, this is precisely why I believe that emotional intelligence deserves closer examination, and the current models that describe it clearly contradict each other. If the same abilities can facilitate both compassion and manipulation, then it is important to distinguish between the ability to influence another person’s emotions and the intention to exploit them. Persuading a friend to feel more confident is also a form of emotional influence, but its purpose is fundamentally different from making someone question their own worth.
As emotional intelligence continues to be celebrated in educational, professional, and interpersonal settings, perhaps we should reconsider what we actually value about it. Rather than only measuring how effectively someone recognises or manages emotions, we should also consider the ethical responsibility with which they apply these abilities.
The point of this article is not to give you trust issues (and hopefully, it has not), but to encourage you to trust your instincts. Not everyone who understands you has your best interests at heart, but that definitely does not mean we should become suspicious of everyone who tries to get close to us. There are people who use their intellect to make others feel understood and to contribute to the greater good, and, to me, that is the most inspiring application of all. In the end, the goal should not be to understand people well enough to know how to hurt them, but instead to understand them well enough to know how not to.
Sources:
References
[1] Austin, E. J. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/222406836_Emotional_intelligence_Machiavellianism_and_emotional_manipulation_Does_EI_have_a_dark_side (accessed 2026-11-16).
[2] Babić Čikeš, A.; Tomašić Humer, J. Ability and Trait Emotional Intelligence: Do They Contribute to the Explanation of Prosocial Behaviour? https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10297566/ (accessed 2026-11-16).
[3] Casale, S.; Rugai, L.; Giangrasso, B.; Fioravanti, G. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30668276 (accessed 2026-11-16).
[4] Côté, S.; DeCelles, K. A.; McCarthy, J. M.; Van Kleef, G. A.; Hideg, I. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21775654/ (accessed 2026-11-16).
[5] Grieve, R.; Mahar, D. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/222822268_The_emotional_manipulation-psychopathy_nexus_Relationships_with_emotional_intelligence_alexithymia_and_ethical_position (accessed 2026-11-16).
[6] Mayer, J. D.; Salovey, P. What Is Emotional Intelligence? https://scholars.unh.edu/psych_facpub/422/ (accessed 2026-11-15).
[7] Nguyen. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/2158244020971615 (accessed 2026-11-16).
[8] Paulhus, D. L.; Williams, K. M. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0092656602005056 (accessed 2026-11-16).
[9] Petrides, K. V. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21314254/ (accessed 2026-11-16).
[10] Porter; Brinke; Baker; Wallace. Apa Psycnet. https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2011-11737-012 (accessed 2026-11-15).
[11] Salovey; Mayer. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.2190/dugg-p24e-52wk-6cdg (accessed 2026-11-16).
[12] Segon, M.; Booth, C. Virtue: The Missing Ethics Element in Emotional Intelligence – Journal of Business Ethics. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10551-013-2029-z (accessed 2026-11-15).
Spotted an error? Email [email protected] from your Wesleyan account.